Member-only story
University of Idaho Murders: E/X As Targets Mean Sigma Chi; M/K As Targets Mean Some “Jacks”

I wrote a little bit about various “targeting” theories earlier in this case:
It seems like the arc of Internet sleuthdom on this case was:
- Kaylee must be the target.
- It was probably some combo of Kaylee and Maddie.
- No, no — it was Ethan.
- OK, no. It was Ethan and Xana.
- Maybe it was all four?
- It must have been Ethan or Kaylee because they weren’t necessarily supposed to be in the house.
- OK, back to Kaylee or Kaylee and Maddie.
I don’t think we know the target. However, I do think the Moscow Police came out early and said “This was targeted…” because there was some evidence of overkill or other items in the house showcasing a singular focus. Obviously they did reverse that at one point and say “Stay vigilant,” but their initial reaction seemed to be: This is targeted.
I think a lot of people think it must be Kaylee and Maddie because they’re hot young things. That’s potentially true, but also could be a reflection of Internet culture.
Our new navel-gaze is this:

If that is Jack D, then you need to start thinking about his alibi.
But, remember:
- He was cleared pretty fast, which means he probably went in and did some tests with them.
- The Goncalves family mostly seems to be…